Women Play Chess. Men Are Stuck at Draughts.

She is playing chess — anticipating, planning, holding the entire household in her head. He is playing draughts — reacting when something lands in front of him. A brutally honest look at the mental load gap, why therapy softens the truth, and the one question that actually matters.

Published 20 May 2026 by Winnie S.

Publio Morbiducci, Couple with White Horse (1944)
Publio Morbiducci, Couple with White Horse (1944)

So we're in couples therapy. Both of us sitting there. The therapist is trying, bless her, she really is, redirecting every time the same argument starts up again, the one we've been having for years, same words, same positions, same outcome. She tilts her head and says something careful and reframing and I watch it land on him and I think, that's going straight over his head. Not because he's not listening. He's listening. He's nodding. But there's a version of what she just said that requires you to have already been thinking three moves ahead and he hasn't been, he never has been, and no amount of careful reframing is going to build that capacity in a fifty minute session.

What I actually needed wasn't a therapist. I needed an anger translator. Someone who could take everything I've been saying in the diplomatic softened version I use because I've learned that the direct version makes me difficult, and just say it plainly. What she means is she's been carrying the mental architecture of this entire relationship inside her head for years and she is tired in a way that sleep does not fix. What she means is she's playing chess and you're playing draughts and she's exhausted of covering the gap.

That's what I needed someone to say. A therapist never will, because therapists are trained to protect everyone's ego simultaneously, to hold space, to reflect back, to gently suggest without ever pointing and saying you, specifically you, are the problem, here it is in writing, nothing more I can do. A business coach would. A business coach sits across from you and says your business is failing because of these specific choices and here is what needs to change. Brutal, useful, honest. But in a therapy office everyone's feelings are being managed at once and so the truth gets so softened by the time it reaches him that it stops feeling like truth and starts feeling like a suggestion and suggestions are very easy to not act on.

The Chess Thing

Chess requires you to hold multiple futures in your mind at once. You're not responding to what just happened. You're already three, four, five moves ahead, running scenarios, anticipating needs before they become problems, managing the present and the future simultaneously. Women in long term relationships do this constantly. The dentist appointment that needs booking. The school kit that needs washing before Thursday. The birthday card for his mother. The cereal that specific child will actually eat. The emotional temperature of everyone in the house. All of it running in the background, all of it held, all of it managed before it becomes anyone else's problem.

Draughts is reactive. You wait for something to happen and then you move.

Most men are playing draughts in a household that requires chess and the woman has been covering the gap so seamlessly for so long that he has never had to notice it. The anticipation is invisible precisely because it works. And a 2023 review of 31 studies confirmed what every woman already knew, that this invisible work of planning, tracking, and emotionally managing family life falls disproportionately on women, and those carrying more of it report significantly higher stress and lower relationship satisfaction. Not a surprise. Just finally in print.

Research from University College London found that women's brains engage differently in anticipation of emotional events, preparing and mapping in ways men's brains don't consistently show. So this isn't just a social pattern. It is partly neurological, partly the result of a lifetime of being the person expected to notice. We didn't choose this. It was assigned before we were old enough to question it, and by the time we were old enough to question it we'd already been doing it so long it felt like personality.

It is not personality. It is adaptation. There is a difference.

He Can Plan. He Just Doesn't.

And here is the part that gets me. He can plan. There is evidence of this. He can execute a business strategy across three financial quarters. He can organise a weekend away for fifteen people without a single dropped detail. He can remember the exact score of a match from 2009. But he cannot remember that swimming lessons are every Saturday. Not because he can't. Because he has never had to. Because I was always there covering it. Because the game was always being played around him by other people and he was comfortable enough outside it that he never needed to learn the rules.

You get exhausted of always being the one playing. You want someone to take a turn. Not perfectly. Not without dropping anything. Just to try. To actually try.

How Do You Know Before

And so you start asking yourself the question I was turning over in my head while the therapist was doing her very best, which is how do you know before. Before the ten years and the children and the resentment that has settled into your chest like sediment. How do you look at someone at the beginning and know whether they are capable of learning to play chess or whether they are a draughts player for life.

The Age Gap Pattern

Which brings me to the age gap thing. Because I think about it and it makes complete sense to me in a way that is deeply uncomfortable. A forty five year old man with a twenty two year old woman. We talk about it like chemistry, like preference, like he just happened to fall for someone younger. But if you've been playing chess long enough you start to see the pattern differently. A twenty two year old hasn't had her formative years yet. She hasn't spent a decade being the one who holds everything. She doesn't know yet what she's agreeing to. She hasn't learned what the game costs. So she's easier. She'll take what's offered. She doesn't yet have the pattern recognition to see what's actually happening.

Give her ten or fifteen years and she'll wake up.

Some men who cannot find a woman their own age interesting cannot find her interesting because a woman their own age has figured out the game. She sees the moves. She knows what questions to ask. She is not going to be poured into. And that is inconvenient if what you want is someone who doesn't notice what you're not doing.

The Only Checklist That Matters

I don't know if there's a screening process rigorous enough to catch this early. I genuinely don't know. Maybe it's one of those things you can only see clearly once you're inside it, once the ordinary machinery of a shared life reveals who each person actually is when nothing is romantic and it's just Tuesday and someone has to hold it all.

But if I were handing a younger version of myself a checklist, it wouldn't ask if he's kind. Kind is easy. It wouldn't ask if he loves you. Love is never actually the problem. It would ask one thing.

Does he notice. Without being told. Does his anticipation extend past himself into the space between you.

That's the test.

The therapist is wrapping up. He seems lighter, he always does after these sessions, and I am sitting with the familiar weight of knowing that I understood everything that was said in that room and I am still the only one who did.

Maybe next time I'll bring an anger translator.

Sources

Sex Roles (2023), Systematic Review of 31 Studies on Gendered Mental Labor

Galli et al, Journal of Neuroscience (2011), Sex Differences in Anticipatory Brain Activity

Psychology Today (2025), Four Hidden Resentments That Ruin Relationships

PMC (2023), Gendered Mental Labor in Household and Childcare

More essays · Quizzes · Find support · About · Privacy