When to Ignore the Ick
We've been sold a very specific story about what should and shouldn't turn us off, and it's honestly getting ridiculous. Your ick might say more about you than it does about them.
Published 7 February 2026 by Winnie S.

We need to talk about the propaganda machine that is modern television and what it's done to our tolerance for actual human beings.
I'm talking about "the ick", that visceral, gut-turning moment when your perfectly adequate partner does something that suddenly makes you want to run for the hills. Maybe they chewed too loudly. Maybe they wore Crocs. Maybe they (God forbid) ran after a ping pong ball with a bit too much enthusiasm. And just like that, according to TikTok and every reality dating show on the planet, you're supposed to ghost them and move on to the next contestant because clearly this person is fundamentally incompatible with you.
Here's the thing though: we've been sold a very specific story about what should and shouldn't turn us off, and it's honestly getting ridiculous.
Let's Talk About Sex (Because It's Actually Relevant)
Right, so the first example that comes to mind when we're talking about objectively icky things that we somehow manage to accept in relationships? Sex. Stay with me here.
Sex is, if we're being honest, kind of gross. There. I said it. It's a completely normal human habit, actually quite an essential one if we're going to continue the species, but that doesn't make it any less objectively strange when you think about it for more than five seconds. We're talking about fluid exchange. Sweat. Sounds. The fact that what turns one person on might make another person want to fake their own death and move to another country.
From period sex to butt play, from different fetishes that definitely do not fit all, to the general reality that bodies do weird things and make weird noises at inopportune moments, sex is full of potentially icky situations. And yet, somehow, when we care about someone, we find ways to be okay with it. We navigate it. We even manage to enjoy it.
So why is it that we can deal with all of that but lose our minds when someone picks their nose?
The TV Propaganda Machine
Here's where the TV propaganda comes in. Every dating show, every rom-com, every bloody series about twenty-somethings navigating love in impossibly gorgeous apartments they definitely can't afford, they all sell us the same story: that minor quirks and habits are actually massive red flags in disguise. That if something gives you "the ick," it's your body's way of telling you this person isn't The One.
Research from 2025 reveals that 64% of people have experienced the ick, and here's the kicker: 26% terminated their relationship immediately because of it, while another 42% ended it later. Only 32% actually stuck around despite the ick. And most people (72%) never even mentioned it to their partner.
Think about that for a second. We're out here ending perfectly functional relationships because someone ate their toast wrong, and we can't even be bothered to say "Hey, that thing you do? It's weird. Can we talk about it?"
The research gets even more interesting. Turns out, only 6% of ick triggers are about physical appearance. The rest? Personality traits and behaviors. Women are most concerned about men being "too feminine" (whatever that means), while men's biggest concern is women being "too trendy" (again, what?). The common threads are things like public embarrassment and annoying speech patterns.
Here's what really gets me: the study found that people who experience the ick more frequently tend to have higher levels of narcissism and perfectionism. As the researchers put it, "There is an indication that 'the ick' is less about genuine incompatibility, and more about unrealistic expectations and deviation of an ideal partner."
In other words, your ick might say more about you than it does about them.
The Uncomfortable Truth About Facts of Life
What we're really dealing with is our collective inability to handle uncomfortable truths about being human. Bodies are weird. People have habits. Nobody is performing for Netflix cameras in their actual relationship, and thank God for that because who wants to live like that?
Your partner picks their nose? Okay, first of all, research suggests nearly everyone does it (they just lie about it). Second, is this really a bigger deal than the fact that you willingly share bodily fluids with this person? Can they change it? Can you have an actual conversation about it like two adults instead of internally cataloguing it as evidence that you should break up?
Because here's the thing that reality TV won't tell you: a nose-picking partner with the ability to change is not necessarily a deal-breaker. A partner who refuses to hear your concerns? That's a different conversation. But most of these icks aren't even about harmful behavior, they're about minor quirks that we've been conditioned to view as relationship-ending offenses.
What The Research Actually Tells Us
A 2022 study found that people with avoidant attachment styles often cope with intimacy by focusing on minor flaws in their partners. The ick becomes a convenient excuse to maintain emotional distance. It's a self-defensive mechanism, a way to protect against relationship failure, fear of commitment, or rejection sensitivity before any of those things actually happen.
Another study in 2023 explored how our inability to be authentic in relationships is making things worse. When everyone around you is "getting the ick" over the smallest things, you start curating yourself to avoid rejection. This creates a cycle of shallow interactions where nobody feels safe showing their true selves. The fear of someone getting the ick over your quirks makes you hide them, which means you never actually develop genuine intimacy.
And perhaps most tellingly, research shows that constant exposure to media's unrealistic romantic narratives actively skews our expectations. When you watch enough reality dating shows, you start to believe that finding love should involve zero awkwardness, perfect timing, and instant chemistry that never wanes. Real relationships, which involve compromise, communication, and yes, tolerating your partner's weird eating habits, start to feel like settling.
The Culture of Rejection
Julia Lippman, a researcher at the University of Michigan, points out that young people's minds are essentially free for media to mold when it comes to relationships. We're interested in figuring out how relationships work but tend to have limited personal experience to draw on, so we look to TV and film for guidance. And what do we see? People breaking up over minor incompatibilities. Characters who are supposedly in love but can't handle basic human flaws.
The result? We've created what experts call a "rejection mindset" that undermines dating success. We're so busy looking for reasons to reject people that we miss opportunities for real connection. One study found that most people can't even tell the difference between a harmless ick and an actual red flag anymore, they've all blurred together into one big category of "reasons to end it."
So What Do We Do About It?
Look, I'm not saying you should stay with someone who fundamentally doesn't respect you or who exhibits genuinely problematic behavior. If someone's rude to waitstaff, constantly talks over you, or shows signs of manipulative behavior, those aren't icks. Those are red flags, and you should absolutely pay attention to them.
But if the main issue is that they laugh weird or wear socks with sandals or have a slightly annoying text tone? Maybe take a beat before you decide this is relationship-ending material.
Here's my radical suggestion: try talking about it. I know, revolutionary. But seriously, if something bothers you, especially something that's a habit rather than a personality trait, have an actual conversation. "Hey, I know this is weird, but could you maybe not do [thing] around me? It bothers me for some reason."
Most people, when approached with kindness and honesty, will try to accommodate you. And if they can't change it, or if they get defensive about being asked? Well, then you have more information about whether this person is actually compatible with you.
The Bottom Line
We've been trained by a steady diet of reality TV and rom-coms to believe that relationships should be effortlessly perfect and that any friction means you're with the wrong person. But real relationships involve two actual humans with actual bodies and actual habits, and some of those habits are going to be annoying or weird or yes, even icky.
The question isn't "Does this person ever do anything that bothers me?" because the answer will always be yes. The question is "Can we navigate the uncomfortable truths about being human together?"
Sex is messy and involves fluids and sometimes farts at inappropriate moments, and somehow we're all okay with that when we care about someone. Your partner's weird chewing sounds are, objectively, much less icky than that. The fact that we've been convinced otherwise says more about media literacy than it does about genuine relationship compatibility.
So the next time you get the ick, pause. Ask yourself: Is this a real incompatibility, or have I just watched too much Love Island? Is this about them, or is this about my own discomfort with intimacy? Can this actually be addressed through communication?
And maybe, just maybe, we can all collectively agree to stop letting reality TV producers dictate what should and shouldn't be relationship deal-breakers in our actual, ordinary, perfectly imperfect relationships.
Because here at Ordinary Relationship, we're here for the real stuff. The awkward, the uncomfortable, the "nobody would put this in a TV show because it's too mundane" moments that actually make up most of a relationship. And sometimes that means sticking around despite the ick.
What are your thoughts on the ick? Have you ever ended a relationship over something minor that you later regretted? Or stuck it out and realized it wasn't actually a big deal? Let us know, we're building a community of people who celebrate ordinary relationships, quirks and all.