How to Tell if You're Leaving Over Small Things or Actual Red Flags
We live in this weird moment where people can finally leave relationships that don't work. But somewhere in this newfound freedom we've also created a culture where people feel justified leaving over anything. How do you know which is which?
Published 21 March 2026 by Winnie S.

We live in this weird moment in history where for the first time in centuries people, especially women, can actually leave relationships that don't work, can walk away without financial ruin or social ostracism, can choose themselves over staying in something miserable, and that's genuinely revolutionary, it's only been about fifty years since this became possible at scale, since women gained enough economic independence and social permission to say this isn't working and actually leave.
And the result is that a lot of people who absolutely should not be together are finally separating, people escaping genuinely toxic situations, abusive dynamics, relationships that were only held together by economic necessity or social pressure, and watching that happen, watching people claim their right to leave, is beautiful in a way, it's the careful curated patriarchal agenda coming apart at the seams, all those rules about marriage and family being the only acceptable structure for human connection finally loosening enough that people can breathe.
But somewhere in this newfound freedom we've also created this culture where people feel justified leaving over anything, over toilet paper direction and dishes in the sink and the way someone chews, and I can't tell if that's liberation or if we've overcorrected, if we've gone from being trapped in terrible relationships to being too quick to abandon salvageable ones, and the honest answer is probably both, probably some people are leaving over genuinely small things because we've lost the muscle for working through difficulty, and some people are leaving over toilet paper because the toilet paper is actually just the visible tip of something much larger they can't articulate yet.
The difficulty is knowing which is which, knowing whether you're being reasonable or whether you're being the kind of person who blows up their life over nothing, and there's no clear answer, no formula that tells you definitively whether your annoyance is legitimate or whether you're just tired because daylight saving happened and your whole body clock is off and you're picking fights because you're operating on low battery and taking it out on the nearest person.
Someone I know confided that their partner does small acts of revenge after arguments, puts vinegar in their mouthwash bottle or lets air out of their tires, nothing major enough to call the police over but enough to make them feel unsafe, enough to realize that this person they love is also someone who wants to harm them when they're angry, and that's not an insignificant squabble, that's a serious problem that needs real attention, that's the kind of thing you should probably leave over because someone who punishes you with petty sabotage is showing you who they become under stress.
But that's obvious, anyone can see that tire slashing is a red flag, the hard part is all the stuff in between, the chronic lateness, the mess they leave everywhere, the way they never plan anything, the fact that you're always the one initiating, the small disappointments that accumulate over time until you're not sure if you're in a bad relationship or if you've just forgotten how to be patient with another human's flaws.
For centuries people didn't have the option to leave over small things, they had to stay, had to find ways to tolerate and adapt and survive, and maybe that created resilience, maybe it taught people to distinguish between the dealbreakers and the merely annoying, but it also trapped people in genuinely terrible situations with no escape, so we can't romanticize that past, can't pretend that being forced to stay was somehow better just because it meant fewer divorces.
What we're navigating now is historically unprecedented, this idea that relationships should make you happy, that you deserve to feel fulfilled, that if something's not working you can just leave, and that's not wrong exactly, you do deserve happiness, you should leave if things are genuinely bad, but it's also created this expectation that relationships shouldn't be difficult, that if you're fighting or annoyed or bored that means you're with the wrong person rather than that you're in the normal ebb and flow of long-term partnership.
The thing is, people are flawed, fundamentally and irreparably flawed, and finding someone whose particular set of flaws doesn't drive you insane is already a miracle, finding someone you can build a family unit with out of thin air, create this shared life despite being two completely separate people with different histories and needs and ways of being, that's remarkable, and throwing that away because they don't stack the dishwasher right feels wasteful even though I also understand that sometimes the dishwasher thing isn't about the dishwasher, it's about feeling unseen or disrespected or like you're the only one trying.
But how do you tell, how do you know whether you're experiencing normal relationship friction that requires patience and communication, or whether you're in something that's slowly eroding your sense of self and you need to get out, and the answer is probably that you can't know with certainty, you're just making your best guess with incomplete information, trying to distinguish between your partner being human and your partner being harmful.
What might help is practical tools for managing the small stuff, the things that are genuinely just about being tired or hormonal or stressed rather than about fundamental incompatibility, like syncing your period tracking apps so you both know when you're likely to be sensitive or reactive, so you can say to each other "I'm PMS-ing and everything feels like a catastrophe, can we just be gentle today" instead of picking fights without realizing why everything feels so raw.
Or having language for low capacity days, being able to say "I'm at about twenty percent today, do you have my back or are you also running on empty," and if you're both depleted you can make different choices, you can order food instead of cooking, you can skip the social obligation, you can give each other space, but if one of you has capacity you can take over, you can carry more that day knowing that next week it might be reversed.
The red flag is when you say "I'm at my lowest" and your partner always tries to compete by being worse than you are, always needs to be more tired, more stressed, more overwhelmed, never has capacity to support you because they're always more of a victim, and that pattern over time tells you something important, tells you they either don't care about your feelings or they're chronically in victim mode, they're workaholics who can't slow down, they're fundamentally selfish when it matters, and those aren't people you can build sustainable partnerships with.
But one instance of them also being tired when you're tired doesn't tell you that, you need repeated data, you need to see whether this is a pattern or whether you just both had a hard week, and making that distinction requires patience and observation rather than immediate judgment.
The ambivalence I feel about all this is real, because sometimes you do just know something is off, sometimes you can't articulate what's wrong but you feel it in your body, this sense that you're not safe or you're not valued or you're slowly disappearing, and I don't want to tell people to ignore that instinct, that gut feeling that says leave is sometimes the most important information you have, it's your subconscious processing patterns your conscious mind hasn't caught up to yet.
But other times that instinct is just fear or self-sabotage or the influence of a culture that tells you if it's not perfect it's not worth having, and distinguishing between legitimate intuition and neurotic anxiety is genuinely difficult, it requires self-knowledge most people don't have, requires being able to separate your childhood wounds from present reality, requires honesty about whether you're running from a bad situation or running from intimacy itself.
What might help is actually writing it down, taking the things that bother you and sorting them into categories, not to get a definitive answer but to externalize the thoughts, to see patterns you can't see when everything's just swirling around in your head making you anxious.
Try This: The Red Flag vs Human Flaw Exercise
Get a piece of paper, draw a line down the middle, and sort everything that's bothering you into two columns.
Column 1: Things That Might Be Ordinary Human Traits
- Leaves dishes in sink sometimes
- Forgot to call when running late
- Snapped at me when overtired
- Different opinions on money/tidiness/how to spend weekends
- Takes longer to make decisions than I do
- Needs more alone time than I'd prefer
- Morning person when I'm a night person
- Messy when I like things organized
- Conflict-avoidant when I prefer direct discussion
- Spends money differently than I would
- Has annoying habits (chewing, snoring, leaving cupboards open)
- Gets stressed about things I don't find stressful
- Processes emotions differently than I do
Column 2: Things That Might Actually Be Red Flags
- Acts of revenge after arguments (sabotage, punishment, spite)
- Competes to be more of a victim when I need support
- Dismisses my feelings consistently
- Makes me feel unsafe or anxious in their presence
- Controls where I go or who I see
- Criticizes me in front of others
- Refuses to discuss problems or shuts down completely
- Lies about significant things repeatedly
- Checks my phone/email without permission
- Threatens to leave during every argument
- Makes me responsible for their emotional regulation
- Blames me for everything that goes wrong
- Isolates me from friends and family
- Shows cruelty to animals, children, service workers
- Escalates anger to frightening levels
Now look at what you've written and ask yourself:
For Column 1 items: Have I actually communicated that this bothers me, or am I just expecting them to know? Is this a pattern or occasional occurrence? Does it happen more when we're both stressed? Can I trace this to my own childhood issues or is it genuinely about them? Would I be annoyed by this in anyone or is it specific to them? Am I willing to work on my own flaws with the same energy I'm expecting them to work on theirs?
For Column 2 items: Is this happening repeatedly or was it one bad moment? Does the pattern escalate or stay stable? Do I feel smaller or less myself over time? Am I making excuses for behavior I'd tell a friend to leave over? Do I feel afraid or just frustrated? When I imagine telling someone I trust about this, would they be concerned?
This exercise won't give you a definitive answer, it won't tell you whether to stay or go, but it might help you see whether you're dealing with normal relationship friction that requires communication and compromise, or whether you're in something that's genuinely harming you that you need to exit.
The couples who make it long-term aren't the ones who never annoy each other, they're the ones who can distinguish between the annoying and the unacceptable, who can say "this drives me crazy but it's not a dealbreaker" about the dishes while also being clear that acts of revenge or emotional cruelty are absolutely dealbreakers, no negotiation, no second chances.
And maybe what we need in this moment of unprecedented freedom to leave is not to go back to forcing people to stay, but to develop better tools for discerning when leaving serves you and when it's just running from the ordinary difficulty of being with another human, because relationships are difficult, they require patience and forgiveness and tolerance for imperfection, but they shouldn't require you to accept harm, shouldn't ask you to diminish yourself, shouldn't make you feel chronically unsafe or unvalued.
The small stuff, the dishes and the toilet paper and the way they breathe too loudly sometimes, that's just being human, that's what you sign up for when you build a life with another person, and if you can't tolerate human flaws you're going to be leaving relationships forever, always chasing some perfect partner who doesn't exist, but the big stuff, the cruelty and control and contempt, that's not small, that's not about learning patience, that's about recognizing when someone is showing you they're not safe to build a life with.
The difficulty is that the line between small and big isn't always clear, sometimes what looks small is actually big, sometimes years of dishes in the sink is actually about fundamental disrespect, and sometimes what looks big is actually small, sometimes the argument that feels relationship-ending is actually just daylight saving and low blood sugar and you both need to eat something and sleep and try again tomorrow.
So maybe the goal isn't to have perfect discernment, isn't to always know with certainty whether to stay or go, maybe it's just to keep asking the question, keep checking in with yourself, keep being honest about what you're experiencing, and trust that over time, with attention and honesty, you'll know what your particular situation requires, whether that's more patience or an exit plan.
Need a break from serious relationship analysis? Try our [fun couples games](/play) for some lighthearted connection.
---
References:
Coontz, S. (2005). Marriage, a History: How Love Conquered Marriage. Penguin Books.
Gottman, J. M., & Silver, N. (2015). The Seven Principles for Making Marriage Work. Harmony Books.
Walker, L. E. (2009). The Battered Woman Syndrome (3rd ed.). Springer Publishing Company.