Letting Your Guard Down Is the Real Fairytale

The first time you cried in front of them, you watched their face for the flinch. It didn't come. They passed you the kitchen roll and sat down on the floor with you.

Published 3 November 2026 by Winnie S.

Strolling along the Seashore, Joaquín Sorolla (1909), Museo Sorolla, Madrid. Public domain via Wikimedia Commons.
Strolling along the Seashore, Joaquín Sorolla (1909), Museo Sorolla, Madrid. Public domain via Wikimedia Commons.

The first time you cried in front of them, you watched their face for the flinch. It didn't come. They passed you the kitchen roll and sat down on the floor with you.

Most of us still remember that day, even if we forget anniversaries.

We remember because the shell came off, and the shell is load-bearing. You built it yourself, for reasons that were sound at the time. The world taught you early that softness gets used. For many women this is not a figure of speech. The World Health Organization estimates that about one in three women worldwide, some 840 million, have been subjected to physical and/or sexual violence in their lifetime, by an intimate partner or by someone else, and that definition includes psychological abuse and controlling behaviour [2](https://www.who.int/news-room/factsheets/detail/violence-against-women). Some were assaulted. Some had close encounters. Some were worn down by words until they couldn't tell which kind they'd had, only that it hurt. Nobody builds armour without a reason.

So a woman walking into new love often walks in carrying all of it: the guard, the hypervigilance, the rehearsed exits. The fairytale she was promised never explains what to do with the armour. Hollywood doesn't either. The fireworks come before anyone has seen each other crack, which is exactly when the important part hasn't happened yet.

The rarest thing you can be given is a person who could take advantage of your vulnerability and doesn't. Not flowers, not jealousy dressed up as devotion, not a speech. A person who holds the space while the shell cracks, and stays for what's underneath. This is, quietly, the biggest green flag of all, because it asks for three things at once and people rarely have one of them, let alone all three: empathy, trust, respect. A love built on those doesn't fade at the first sign of trouble. It's the kind that still loves you on your shittiest morning, when you've said mean things you'd take back if your pride let you, and they come and sit down next to you anyway.

The researchers have been circling this for decades. Harry Reis and Phillip Shaver described intimacy as a loop in 1988: you reveal something, your partner responds with understanding and care, and you feel safe enough to reveal a bit more next time [3](https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC2698051/). Intimacy isn't one big confession. It's hundreds of small ones, each met kindly, until the reveal stops being an event. Attachment researchers call a partner like this a safe haven: Collins and Feeney found that people who could turn to a responsive partner in distress coped better and grew braver, not softer [4](https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC2698051/). Stephen Porges mapped the same thing from the inside out: a nervous system near someone safe actually settles. Heart rate drops. Shoulders come down. The performance ends.

Brené Brown interviewed hundreds of women about shame for her grounded theory research and found that shame survives silence and loses its grip when it's spoken, and that mutually empathic relationships were what let women put it down [1](https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/10.1606/1044-3894.3483). Her larger finding from twelve years of work: vulnerability is our most accurate measure of courage [5](https://prhinternationalsales.com/book/?isbn=9781592408412). The thing we were trained to hide is the thing that lets love in.

And the training is not subtle. Boys get raised to close themselves off and be strong. Women get raised to hold the entire world on their shoulders. Two people raised like that meet and fall in love, and each of them waits for the other to go first. The load stays up for years while both stand under it, heroic and quiet. The gift, when it finally comes, is one of them dropping it and saying, "I see you, and you see me." No better gift exists. I've been given it and I'd take it over any honeymoon I've heard described.

Which is why it cannot happen in the infatuation phase or the honeymoon phase. Those phases have no bad days in them yet. Nobody has been at their shittiest. You cannot hand someone your worst and watch them stay until you have actually been your worst. Only the deep, long-term commitment phase runs that test, and that's where it can breed a love so settled and so strong that nothing shakes it apart, short of death itself. The shell you built to survive the world gets opened, gently, by someone who had every chance to use it and never did.

Castles in fairytales have walls and moats, and we always assumed the walls were the romance. The love story isn't the castle, though. It's the morning someone lowers the drawbridge and the other person walks in gently. Then they put down the stone they've been carrying, and so do you.

References

World Health Organization (2023), Violence against women prevalence estimates. Brown (2006), Families in Society, "Shame Resilience Theory"; Brown (2012), Daring Greatly. Reis & Shaver (1988), "Intimacy as an interpersonal process", Handbook of Personal Relationships. Collins & Feeney (2000), Journal of Personality and Social Psychology. Porges (2011), The Polyvagal Theory.

More essays · Quizzes · Find support · About · Privacy